Run Rules in Simple Terms
A point beyond the control limits is the most obvious signal on a control chart. But a process can drift without crossing a limit. Run rules catch those patterns earlier by looking at sequences of points.
The best-known sets are the Western Electric rules (1956) and the eight Nelson rules (1984). AIAG SPC materials list similar tests.
Common Rules
| Pattern | What it may mean |
|---|---|
| 1 point beyond 3 sigma | Sudden large shift or error |
| 2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma, same side | Shift in the mean |
| 4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma, same side | Smaller shift in the mean |
| 8 or more points in a row on one side of the centre | Process mean has moved |
| 6 points in a row steadily rising or falling | Trend, such as tool wear |
| 14 points alternating up and down | Two sources mixed, such as two machines |
Example
An X-bar chart for a turned diameter shows seven subgroups in a row rising steadily, all inside the limits. The trend rule flags it. The operator checks the insert, finds wear, changes it and records the action on the chart before any part goes out of tolerance.
Using Run Rules Well
Each extra rule raises the chance of a false alarm, so pick a set that suits the process and the customer, and apply it consistently. Every signal should lead to a recorded reaction from the control plan. OperaHive SPC software lets you choose Basic, Western Electric, Nelson, AIAG or Wheeler rules, or configure your own. For more, read the SPC and Cpk guide.