What Is Run Rules?

Definition

Run Rules are tests applied to a control chart to detect non-random patterns, such as trends or runs on one side of the centre line, that signal a special cause even when no point is outside the control limits.

Run Rules in Simple Terms

A point beyond the control limits is the most obvious signal on a control chart. But a process can drift without crossing a limit. Run rules catch those patterns earlier by looking at sequences of points.

The best-known sets are the Western Electric rules (1956) and the eight Nelson rules (1984). AIAG SPC materials list similar tests.

Common Rules

PatternWhat it may mean
1 point beyond 3 sigmaSudden large shift or error
2 of 3 points beyond 2 sigma, same sideShift in the mean
4 of 5 points beyond 1 sigma, same sideSmaller shift in the mean
8 or more points in a row on one side of the centreProcess mean has moved
6 points in a row steadily rising or fallingTrend, such as tool wear
14 points alternating up and downTwo sources mixed, such as two machines

Example

An X-bar chart for a turned diameter shows seven subgroups in a row rising steadily, all inside the limits. The trend rule flags it. The operator checks the insert, finds wear, changes it and records the action on the chart before any part goes out of tolerance.

Using Run Rules Well

Each extra rule raises the chance of a false alarm, so pick a set that suits the process and the customer, and apply it consistently. Every signal should lead to a recorded reaction from the control plan. OperaHive SPC software lets you choose Basic, Western Electric, Nelson, AIAG or Wheeler rules, or configure your own. For more, read the SPC and Cpk guide.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Still unsure? Ask our team.

What are run rules in SPC?

Run rules are tests applied to control charts to detect non-random patterns, such as trends or shifts, that suggest a special cause even when no point is beyond the control limits.

What are the Western Electric rules?

They are four rules published by Western Electric in 1956: one point beyond 3 sigma, 2 of 3 beyond 2 sigma, 4 of 5 beyond 1 sigma on one side, and 8 in a row on one side of the centre line.

What are the Nelson rules?

They are eight tests published by Lloyd Nelson in 1984 for spotting special causes on control charts, building on the earlier Western Electric rules.

Western Electric rules vs Nelson rules: what is the difference?

The Western Electric rules have four tests. The Nelson rules have eight, adding tests for trends, alternating points, stratification and mixtures.

What is a run of 7 in SPC?

A run of 7 means seven consecutive points on the same side of the centre line. Many plants treat it as a signal that the process mean may have shifted.

What is a trend on a control chart?

A trend is a series of points steadily increasing or decreasing, often six or seven in a row. It can indicate tool wear or gradual change in material or temperature.

Should I use all run rules?

Not always. Using every rule increases false alarms. Many plants use a smaller set agreed with their customer.

What should an operator do when a run rule is broken?

Follow the reaction plan in the control plan: stop or flag the process, check recent parts, look for a cause, record the action on the chart and notify the supervisor if required.

Do run rules apply to attribute charts?

Yes, the basic rules can be used on p, np, c and u charts, though some zone-based tests are less reliable when the data is not close to normal.

Can SPC software apply run rules automatically?

Yes. SPC software can check each new point against the selected rules and alert the operator, which avoids missed signals on paper charts.

Put Run Rules Into Practice

Book a demo and see how OperaHive handles this on your own parts, processes and documents.