What Is Design FMEA (DFMEA)?

Definition

Design Failure Mode and Effects Analysis (DFMEA) is a structured review of a product design that identifies how the design could fail, what the effects would be, and which actions will reduce the risk before the design is released.

DFMEA in Simple Terms

A DFMEA asks one question about every function of a product: how could the design fail to do this? The team lists each failure mode, its effect on the customer and its cause in the design, then rates the risk and plans actions. It focuses on the design itself and assumes the part will be made to the drawing.

In automotive, most suppliers now follow the AIAG and VDA FMEA Handbook published in 2019, which replaced the RPN with Action Priority. DFMEA is a phase 2 deliverable in APQP.

How It Works

  1. Planning and preparation: define scope, team and timing.
  2. Structure analysis: break the product into system, subsystem and component.
  3. Function analysis: list what each element must do.
  4. Failure analysis: link failure effects, modes and causes.
  5. Risk analysis: rate severity, occurrence and detection and assign Action Priority.
  6. Optimisation: plan and complete actions, then re-rate.
  7. Results documentation: record and communicate the outcome.

DFMEA vs PFMEA

DFMEAPFMEA
FocusProduct designManufacturing process
Typical causesMaterial choice, geometry, tolerancesMachine settings, operator error, tooling
OwnerDesign engineeringManufacturing and quality engineering

Example: a DFMEA on a plastic connector latch finds that the latch could crack at low temperature. The team changes the resin grade and adds a cold impact test to the DVP&R, which lowers the occurrence rating.

Why It Matters

Design changes are cheapest before tooling is cut. A good DFMEA also feeds the PFMEA and helps identify special characteristics. OperaHive FMEA software supports DFMEA and PFMEA using the AIAG-VDA method. For more detail, see the FMEA guide.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Still unsure? Ask our team.

When should a DFMEA be done?

Start it early in design, before the design is frozen, and update it whenever the design, its use or field experience changes.

Who owns the DFMEA?

The design responsible party owns it, usually the product engineering team, with input from quality, manufacturing, testing and suppliers.

Does DFMEA still use RPN?

The AIAG-VDA handbook uses Action Priority instead of RPN, although some customers and older FMEAs still use RPN.

What is DFMEA?

DFMEA stands for Design Failure Mode and Effects Analysis. It is a structured method to find how a product design could fail, judge the effects and causes, and plan actions before the design is released.

What is the difference between DFMEA and PFMEA?

DFMEA looks at how the product design could fail to meet its function. PFMEA looks at how the manufacturing process could fail to produce the design as intended.

What are the seven steps of the AIAG-VDA DFMEA?

The AIAG-VDA method uses seven steps:

  • planning and preparation
  • structure analysis
  • function analysis
  • failure analysis
  • risk analysis
  • optimisation
  • results documentation
What is a DFMEA example?

For a brake hose, a failure mode might be a leak at the crimp. The effect is loss of braking, the cause is wrong crimp dimension in the design, and prevention and detection controls include design standards and pressure tests.

What is Action Priority in DFMEA?

Action Priority rates each failure as high, medium or low priority for action, based on severity, occurrence and detection together. It replaced RPN in the AIAG-VDA handbook to put more weight on severity.

What are common DFMEA mistakes?

Common mistakes include starting too late, copying old FMEAs without review, confusing failure modes with causes, rating detection as inspection only and never closing recommended actions.

How is DFMEA linked to the DVP&R?

Detection controls in the DFMEA should map to tests in the DVP&R. Test results then feed back into the DFMEA to confirm or update occurrence and detection ratings.

What is DFMEA software?

DFMEA software builds structure, function and failure networks, applies AIAG-VDA rating tables and links to PFMEAs and control plans. It keeps revisions under control and makes reuse across products easier.

Put Design FMEA (DFMEA) Into Practice

Book a demo and see how OperaHive handles this on your own parts, processes and documents.