Root Cause Analysis in Simple Terms
When a defect is found, the quick fix is to sort the parts and carry on. RCA asks why the defect was made and why it was not caught, then keeps asking until it reaches a cause that can be fixed and verified.
It sits at the heart of CAPA and the 8D method, where it is the fourth discipline.
Common RCA Methods
- 5 Whys: ask why repeatedly until the real cause appears.
- Fishbone diagram: group possible causes under headings such as man, machine, method, material, measurement and environment.
- Is / Is Not analysis: compare where the problem occurs with where it could occur but does not.
- Fault tree analysis: work down from the failure through logical causes.
- Data checks: control charts, Pareto charts and comparisons of good and bad parts.
Example
Holes on a bracket are out of position. Why? The part moved in the fixture. Why? The clamp did not close fully. Why? Chips were trapped under the locator. Why? The coolant nozzle was moved during a tool change and no longer clears the fixture. The fix is a fixed nozzle position and a fixture cleaning check, verified by a capability study.
Common Mistakes
- Stopping at "operator error" without asking why the process allowed the error.
- Finding only the occurrence cause and not why the defect escaped detection.
- Not testing the root cause by turning the problem on and off.
- Closing the action without checking it worked.
OperaHive quality inspection software records nonconformances so investigations start from the inspection data.