What Is Vendor Rating?

Definition

Vendor Rating is a method of scoring suppliers against agreed criteria, usually quality, delivery and cost, so that their performance can be compared and acted on.

Vendor Rating in Simple Terms

Instead of judging suppliers on memory or the last bad delivery, vendor rating turns their record into a number or grade. The score is reviewed regularly, often monthly or quarterly, and shared with the supplier as a scorecard.

How to Calculate It

A common approach is a weighted score. Each criterion is scored out of 100 and multiplied by its weight:

CriterionTypical measureExample weight
QualityRejected parts per million, SCARs raised50 percent
DeliveryOn-time, in-full deliveries30 percent
Cost and servicePrice stability, response to requests20 percent

Scores are then grouped into bands, for example A (preferred), B (acceptable) and C (needs improvement plan).

Example

A supplier scores 80 on quality, 95 on delivery and 90 on cost. The weighted rating is 0.5 x 80 + 0.3 x 95 + 0.2 x 90 = 86.5, which falls in band B. Because quality is its weakest area, the buyer reviews its open SCARs at the next quarterly meeting.

Why It Matters

  • Sourcing decisions are based on data rather than opinion.
  • Weak suppliers get early, specific feedback.
  • It supports supplier evaluation required by ISO 9001 and supports the approved supplier list.

Delivery data starts with purchase orders and goods receipts, which are handled in OperaHive purchase order software.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Still unsure? Ask our team.

What is vendor rating?

Vendor rating is a method of scoring suppliers on measures such as quality, delivery, cost and responsiveness, so they can be compared and managed fairly.

Vendor rating vs supplier scorecard: what is the difference?

They are closely related. Vendor rating is the method of scoring suppliers, and the scorecard is the report that shows the score to the supplier and internal teams.

How often should vendors be rated?

Most manufacturers rate key suppliers monthly or quarterly and smaller suppliers less often, depending on volume and risk.

How do you calculate vendor rating?

Choose criteria, give each a weight, score each criterion on a set scale, then add the weighted scores. For example, quality 40 percent, delivery 30 percent, cost 20 percent and service 10 percent.

What are the methods of vendor rating?

The main methods are the categorical method, the weighted point method and the cost ratio method. The weighted point method is the most common in manufacturing.

What criteria are used in vendor rating?

Typical criteria are defect rate in PPM, on-time delivery, price, response to corrective actions, audit results and communication.

What is a vendor rating example?

A supplier scores 90 on quality, 80 on delivery and 70 on cost. With weights of 50, 30 and 20 percent, its rating is 45 + 24 + 14 = 83 out of 100.

What is a good vendor rating score?

Many companies class scores above 85 or 90 as preferred, 70 to 85 as acceptable and below 70 as needing an improvement plan, but each company sets its own bands.

What happens when a vendor has a low rating?

The supplier is usually asked for an improvement plan, may face extra audits or inspection, and can lose new business or be removed from the approved supplier list if it does not improve.

What are common vendor rating mistakes?

Using too many criteria, changing weights often, relying on manual data that is late or wrong, and not sharing the rating with the supplier so it can improve.

Put Vendor Rating Into Practice

Book a demo and see how OperaHive handles this on your own parts, processes and documents.